For what feels like the first time in months, the hottest trade in the market may not be an AI stock. Shares of Toll Brothers Inc NYSE: TOLthe luxury homebuilder, closed last week at about $148, up about 20% since its earnings report in the back half of May. In context, at the same time, the S&P 500 was almost flat, while other AI darlings that were leading the market higher, such as NVIDIA Corp. NASDAQ: NVDAthey spent more than 10%.
That’s a big difference, and it comes after weeks of seemingly endless gains across the AI and chip space. Investors seem to be taking advantage of the year’s most crowded trades and trading traditional names that have been left behind.
If that’s a trend with legs, then few stocks look better positioned to benefit than Toll Brothers. The company has new earnings momentum, a wave of analyst upgrades behind it, and a valuation that seems to belong in a completely different market. Let’s jump in and take a closer look below.
The Earnings Report That Lit The Fuse
The rally never materialized. Toll Brothers delivered a strong earnings report last month, beating expectations and raising its full-year guidance, reminding investors how well the core business has been performing while the market’s attention has been elsewhere.
Management relies on the company’s unique position as “the nation’s leading builder of luxury homes,” as well as operations that encompass a wide range of markets and a customer base of wealthy buyers who are less sensitive to economic volatility than the average house hunter. That positioning has been a quiet superpower for years, and it shows again in the numbers.
The story of shareholder returns is compelling. The company has been buying back its stock aggressively, which is always a good sign, and recently raised its quarterly dividend. In other words, you have a business firing on all cylinders with managers who are confident enough in their path to buy back their stock.
Valuation is still screaming
This is where the opportunity is most interesting to those of us on the weighing side. Despite the recent surge, Toll Brothers shares are still trading at the same level as nearly two years ago, with a notably weak start to the year before the earnings report turned things around.
A stock-to-earnings (P/E) ratio of 11 underscores the point. In a market where investors are paying 50, 100, or several hundred times earnings for AI exposure, a profitable, equity-growing market leader trading at 10 times earnings looks like something close to a deal. In fact, you’d be forgiven for wondering how it’s stayed so cheap for so long.
The answer, of course, is that the market simply didn’t care about anything but AI. That’s exactly what makes the current rotation so important. If even a part of the capital that has been going into the semis in recent weeks starts looking for a new home, names of a level like this would be the first port of call.
Analysts enter
Toll Brothers Stock Forecast Today
$163.56
11.31% changedBuy Medium
Based on 21 Analyst Ratings
| Current Price | $146.95 |
|---|---|
| High Forecast | $187.00 |
| Average prediction | $163.56 |
| Low Prognosis | $115.00 |
Toll Brothers Stock Forecast Details
What makes this opportunity even more attractive is that the analyst community has also been dependent on power. BTIG Research, for example, upgraded the stock from Neutral to Buy earlier this week, echoing similar Bullish reviews from UBS, Benchmark, and Argus this month already. That’s a remarkable set of developments coming in a very short window, and it tells you that the smart money is starting to account for the situation that’s playing out right now.
The Argus review deserves special mention. Its price of $170 means it’s up 15% from where the stock is trading, and that’s on top of the 20% gain it already posted from last month’s earnings. For a stock that has spent most of the year trending down, that kind of change is hard to ignore.
Critical Rotation Takes It Seriously
Of course, none of this means AI trading is over. The technical story driving those stocks remains a real turning point, and the kind of pullback we’re seeing right now has proven temporary so far. But markets go through cycles of enthusiasm, and after months of one-way traffic in AI terms, a time to balance was always possible.
The question for investors is where that rebalancing money is flowing, and Toll Brothers is making a strong case for itself as a major beneficiary. A market-leading brand that is outperforming valuations, increasing guidance, implementing aggressive buybacks, and growing its profits, while trading at a P/E ratio of just 10, is a rare combination at the best of times. While price action in the AI space is telling investors to be cautious, everything about Toll Brothers is telling them to take a closer look.
Before you consider Toll Brothers, you’ll want to hear this.
MarketBeat tracks Wall Street’s top and most effective research analysts and the stocks they recommend to their clients every day. MarketBeat identified five stocks that top analysts are quietly whispering to their clients to buy now before the broader market catches on… and Toll Brothers wasn’t on the list.
Although Toll Brothers currently has an Average Buy rating among analysts, top analysts believe these five stocks are the best.
View Five Stocks Here
Just getting into the stock market? These 10 simple stocks can help first-time investors build long-term wealth without knowing options, technology, or other advanced strategies.
Get This Free Report
