This week’s news that Applied Materials Inc NASDAQ: AMAT it just surpassed the price-to-market value that held the peak of the dot-com bubble in April 2000 and may have been enough to get even the most dedicated bulls reaching for Pepto.
That’s because headlines comparing stock valuations to the levels of the dot-com bubble often act as a red light for investors. Considering how sad the semiconductor measurement equipment maker is, it’s understandable.
Applied Materials shares hit another all-time high this week, as the multi-month rally continues to gain momentum. Overall, the stock is up more than 140% year to date and a staggering 50% in the past month alone.
That kind of run is the kind that creates new highs, breaks technological models, and, ultimately, attracts headlines like this one. The question for investors is whether that historical comparison is the warning sign it sounds like, or whether the current environment is different enough that a repeat is justified. Let’s jump into it.
Why The Rally Is Absurd
The starting point we need to stick to is that this is not a 1999 style story of a company that is only bought on hope and hype. Applied Materials truly benefits from one of the strongest structures the semiconductor industry has ever seen. The team at Citi made exactly that point earlier this week, raising their price target on the stock as it cited a “structural increase” in NAND demand driven by an explosion in agent AI workloads.
The argument is technical, but still makes good sense when you boil it down. As AI workloads become more complex and demanding, they require much more memory than the fastest and most expensive types of memory can provide. That’s pushing the industry toward cheaper, better alternatives, and Applied Materials sits at the heart of the equipment supply chain that makes those alternatives possible.
Along with ongoing innovation across the wide memory space, Citi’s team sees this change as one that should drive the company’s earnings growth through 2028. That is not a high sugar level. That’s a multi-year trend bulls are betting will continue to drive earnings growth at rates other tech stocks can kill.
Analysts Are Unanimous in Their Opinion
Applied Materials MarketRank™ Stock Analysis
- Overall MarketRank™
- 82nd Percentile
- Analyst rating
- Buy Medium
- Under/Under
- 20.7% Low
- Short Term Interest Rate
- You are healthy
- Dividend Power
- It’s in between
- News Experience
- 1.18
- Insider Trading
- Selling Shares
- Proj. Income Growth
- 31.90%
See Full Analysis
In fact, the consensus rating of average buys and the latest round of analyst price targets is another reason to avoid relying too heavily on dot-com comparisons.
Citi’s $710 target, up from $550, still marks a recent high, and the company isn’t alone.
Barclays, UBS Group and Cantor Fitzgerald are among the firms that have recently reiterated or raised bullish views on Applied Materials.
When well-regarded analysts continue to raise their targets, even after the stock has already gained 140% this year, it tells you something about their confidence in its growth.
The Risks Are Real Too
For all that, though, there’s no escaping the single-track trend of the chart in recent months, or this week’s dot-com headline. The relative strength indicator for Materials is also moving into overbought territory, which can often set the scene for a sharp reset whenever sentiment starts to swing the other way.
There are also real underlying concerns that should not be ignored. About 30% of the company’s revenue comes from China, leaving Applied Materials more exposed to any sudden trade policy disruptions or other restrictions on equipment exports.
How to Build a Position Carefully
For investors looking to get involved, there is a lot to consider. The bull case is real, the demand picture for the building is compelling, and the analyst community is firmly in the camp for higher prices to come. But the chart is also extended, the price is at historically high levels, and one-directional rallies often find their final countdown.
For investors who want to chase this penetration, that probably means resisting the urge to go all in at once and instead building it up in stages. The starting position now, with the behavior of adding to the pullbacks almost before, is probably a smarter way to play this than trying to set the perfect time. The dot-com comparison may make for an uncomfortable topic, but the difference between 2000 and 2026 is that in this case, the need really exists. The trick is to make sure you don’t overpay for it.
Before you consider Materials, you’ll want to hear this.
MarketBeat tracks Wall Street’s top and most effective research analysts and the stocks they recommend to their clients every day. MarketBeat identified five stocks that top analysts are quietly whispering to their clients to buy now before the broader market catches on… and Applied Materials wasn’t on the list.
Although Applied Materials currently has an Average Buy rating among analysts, top analysts believe these five stocks are the best.
View Five Stocks Here
Robotics and automation are quickly becoming critical infrastructure in all sectors of healthcare, manufacturing, transportation, and many other industries.
“Physical AI” is coming to the United States, and there are four ways investors can gain exposure to this new robotics revolution. Plus, learn which seven companies are best positioned to benefit as intelligent robots enter the workplace.
Get This Free Report
