ROBERT MAGINNIS: The US pounds Iran, but one month in, the strategy and the endgame are still elusive
NEWNow you can listen to Fox News articles!
Wars are not defined by tons of weapons used or ships sunk. They are defined by whether military forces serve a corresponding political purpose. One month into Operation Epic Fury, that goal remains unlearned.
On February 28, US and Israeli forces began America’s largest war in the Middle East since Iraq. Iran’s navy has been crippled, its air defenses damaged, and its missile production disrupted. The commanders counted the strikes and the ships sunk the way the Vietnamese commanders counted. Those metrics didn’t tell then-President Lyndon B. Johnson anything about whether he was winning. They don’t tell us anything now.
Military Image
Iran is still fighting. Despite the loss of more than 150 naval vessels and its supreme leader in the opening strikes, the empire did not break. Mojtaba Khamenei was installed as Supreme Leader within days. Last week, an IRGC naval commander was killed in a US strike. No succession problem ensued. An American intelligence assessment confirmed that the regime remained “strong but greatly reduced.” Defamation is invincible.
Iran entered this war already financially broke. It is still being fought. A regime that continues to struggle after the collapse of its financial system will not be deterred by economic pressures alone.
REVOLT IRAN VOWS TO FIGHT ‘TO TOTAL VICTORY,’ DESPITE HEAVY LOSS OF FACE
The rise is accelerating. Secretary of the Army Pete Hegseth announced last week that Operation Epic Fury is “not an endless war” – and on the same day, the Pentagon ordered 2,000 paratroopers from the 82nd Airborne Division to the theater, joining two Marine Expeditionary Units that are on the way. The 82nd is the force entry division of the Army. Its main goal under active planning appears to be the seizure of Kharg Island, Iran’s main oil export hub. No one has publicly revealed an exit strategy.
Weapon stats are brutal. The first six days cost at least 11.3 billion dollars in weapons alone. The US only builds 96 THAAD interceptors per year; a quarter of all livestock was consumed in last year’s 12-day campaign. Iran produces more than 100 ballistic missiles per month. We build six or seven interceptors at the same time. Gen. Dan Caine, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, warned before the war that a long-term campaign would destroy a number of assets critical to deterring China. A war that cannot be sustained statistically cannot be won strategically.
IRAN’S REMAINING WEAPONS: HOW TEHRAN CAN DISRUPT THE HORMUZ CONCLUSION
Economic Devastation
The Strait of Hormuz carries 20 percent of the world’s oil. Its imminent shutdown on February 28 produced the largest power outage since the 1970s. Goldman Sachs has modeled that oil reaching $110 a barrel in one month would increase US inflation to 3.3% and reduce GDP growth to 2.1%. Brent crude reached a peak of $126.
More consistent, and less reported, is helium. Iran’s strikes on Qatar’s Ras Laffan facility—the world’s largest LNG facility—stopped helium production and caused damage that will take years to repair.
Qatar supplies a third of the world’s helium. It is an irreplaceable input in semiconductor manufacturing, space systems, and medical imaging. Without it, chip production stops. There is no other place to do it. This war has threatened the physical supply chain that underlies all the advanced technologies that the US economy and military depend on.
THE WAR IS DRIVING HOME: WHY FINANCIAL PAIN AND ECONOMIC UNCERTAINTY ARE THREATENING TRUMP’S DRIVE TO TOP IRAN
And here’s the truth that the administration isn’t leading on this: Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent revealed this past week that Iran’s financial system collapsed by December 2025—a product of a high-pressure campaign launched a full year before Operation Epic Fury.
Iran entered this war already financially broke. It is still being fought. A regime that continues to struggle after the collapse of its financial system will not be deterred by economic pressures alone.
Political Failure
No end state is defined. Secretary of State Rubio announced that the entire military mission is “active.” Those are kinetic metrics. They say nothing about the political situation the United States intends to produce or how it will know when the war is over.
Secretary Hegseth summed up America’s strategy as “talks and bombs.” That’s Clausewitz in reverse. Clausewitz said that war is the continuation of politics by other means. Hegseth’s invention makes bombs diplomacy. That is not a strategy. That is a war with no political purpose.
TRUMP SLAMS ‘SICK’ IRANIAN LEADERS, CONFIRMS DEADLINE TO END WAR.
Tehran rejected the US’s 15-point ceasefire plan and issued a five-point proposal demanding Iranian sovereignty over the Strait of Hormuz. Iran’s foreign minister said his government is not involved in talks and does not plan any talks. Before the war began, Iran’s negotiators told Special Envoy Witkoff bluntly that they “will not stop talking about what we cannot defeat militarily.” They meant it.
And here’s what President Trump didn’t internalize: He’s misreading the enemy. The Iranian mullahcracy does not work on the concept of bargaining. It works on theology.
The IRGC understands this war through the prism of Mahdism – the doctrine of the Twelver Shia that their messiah, the Hidden Imam, will return at the end of days, and that confronting the US and Israel is not only a secular position but a sacred one.
Radical clerics within the IRGC view their hostility toward the US as preparing the conditions for the Mahdi’s return—a religious obligation, not a negotiating position. A government built on that idea does not collapse because it has been hit hard. It collapses when its internal legitimacy collapses or its material structures are dismantled.
One regional analyst warned that if pushed to the brink, Iran’s leadership would soon “burn everything” rather than accept policies it sees as sacrificing God’s work.
INSIDE THE IRANIAN MILITARY: ACTIVITIES, MILITIAS AND AN ARMY BUILT FOR SURVIVAL
No collapse or disintegration occurred.
Trump seems to be strategizing as he goes. And none of his advisers seem willing to tell him he’s misread the enemy. That is the most dangerous gap in the room.
The Bottom Line
In one month, the record is clear. Iran’s military has been disarmed. The kingdom endures. The Strait remains controversial. The ceasefire was rejected. Thousands of soldiers headed for the theater. Weapons burn faster than the industrial base can replace them.
Standing on the South Lawn last week, Trump declared that from a military point of view, Iran is “done” — while Iran was blocking the Straits behind him.
CLICK HERE TO VIEW MORE FOX NEWS
Meanwhile, the lawmakers sitting in the meeting of the Military Committee came out with a different assessment: “There was no plan, no strategy, no end game shared.” That is not a strategy. That is arrogance with a confident voice.
Sir Alex Younger, a former MI6 chief, last week assessed that Iran had taken over the program and that the conflict was turning into an endurance contest. Strategic success has not produced strategic clarity.
CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD THE FOX NEWS PROGRAM
Wars don’t end when you run out of goals. They disappear when you define success.
In one month, that explanation is still not available.
CLICK HERE TO READ MORE FROM ROBERT MAGINNIS
